Today, this Tweet helped my crystallize why I consider myself agnostic, and motivated me to write a blog post:
I used to be an agnostic too. Then I read the Bible again and it solidified my #atheism - @WiseGuyEddie, via Twitter
The first reason I am agnostic is that I believe that there are many meaningful choices besides Atheism and the Judeo-Christian tradition, and I know almost nothing about most of them. I only have any knowledge of religions that formed out of the Western tradition -- Sumerian, Egyptian, Greek, Norse, and Celtic mythologies; Zoroastrianism, Judaism, Islam, Christianity, and Baha'i; and mystery religions, such as gnosticism, that branched off of the Judeo-Christian religion. I am aware of the religions of the Eastern tradition, such as Hinduism, Buddhism, and Taoism, although I know little about them. I am also aware that the many tribes of the world hewed to pagan religions, but of them I know almost nothing save the odd story. Finally, new religions are constantly being invented, such as Scientology and Raelism. I can say confidently that I do not believe any of the religions that I've examined in any detail. I also have made a decision that it's not worth my time giving each belief system a fair hearing. However, I have to admit that I am ignorant of most of them. So, calling myself agnostic seems like an honest thing to do.
The second reason for being agnostic is positive --- by refusing to take any position, I leave myself the freedom to imagine different possible reasons for the Universe, and test whether I might eliminate some based on the nature of reality. Here are a few of the possibilities I entertain to explain the Universe (none of which I claim are original to me, but I don't remember where I heard them all):
- There might be more than one deity vying to have influence on the Universe.
- God might be evil, and any good that emerges in the world is an accident that violates his design.
- God might have interests and concerns so different from anything we can image that it seems as if God doesn't care.
- God might have created the Universe as a means of seeking a better understanding of what it means to be moral.
- The Universe might be little more than a science fair project by a deity, who might only care about first place.
- The Universe might be the ridiculously detailed hallucination of a madman.
- The Universe might have been created for cats.
- Life on Earth might have been seeded by alien scientists who were attempting to prove to alien clergy that intelligent life could happen by accident.
- As a corollary, alien clergy might have planted the seed of religion with humanity, to prove the point that religion is Universally true.
- The Universe might just be something that exists for no good reason, and we just happen to be here wondering why.
Why would I surrender the option of embracing all these possibilities? Indeed, this is the basis of a proposed new religion of sorts,
Possibilianism.
Thirdly, I embrace agnosticism, and more specifically Possibilianism, because I see it as high ground from which I can tweak those who believe they have the ultimate truth.
To summarize, being Possibilian is the most efficient and entertaining choice of belief systems.